The Just Desserts mystery fiction discussion group discussed the
(supposedly) 3-volume “Carpenter and Quincannon” mystery series by
Marcia Muller and Bill Pronzini for its August 2015 meeting.
The Bughouse Affair
was my first exposure to this series, and I’ll have to admit to some
mixed feelings. The covers of the three volumes put out by Forge all
make it look, vaguely, like these are mysteries crossed with paranormal
and/or science fiction elements. The titles also made me think that —
The Bughouse Affair,
The Spook Lights Affair,
The Body Snatchers Affair.
However, this series turns out to be a pretty straight-forward
historical mystery series, set in 1890s San Francisco. Sabina Carpenter
is a former Pinkerton operative, and the widow of a fellow Pinkerton
agent who died on the job. John Quincannon is a former U.S. Secret
Service agent who left the service after a tragic accident has left him
with a case of post-traumatic shock. Together, they’ve formed a San
Francisco private detection agency. In
The Bughouse Affair,
they are each working on separate cases — she’s tracking a female
pickpocket targeting carnival guests, he’s trying to identify and stop a
skilled burglar who’s hitting the homes of the wealthy. By the end of
the book, the two cases have tied together. I loved Sabina — she’s a
remarkable, strong, level-headed female detective character in a time
period where such accomplishments would be rare. Quincannon, on the
other hand, I never warmed to. He’s bull-headed, brusque and full of
himself. Yet…he’s observant and has uncanny intuition and
stick-to-it-iveness.
I would recommend this series to anyone who likes humorous mysteries,
witty banter or historical mysteries that don’t take themselves too
seriously. At the top of this review, I stated “supposedly 3 volumes”.
As the group discussed this series, we discovered that it is based on a
series of earlier novels and/or story collections by Bill Pronzini
alone, from the 1980s and 1990s, that introduced these characters. If
you like this item, you might like these too – The earlier Carpenter
& Quincannon stories and novels, most of which you would have to get
through the libraries’ InterLibrary Loan service, as they don’t
currently exist in the Lincoln City Libraries’ collection!
[ publisher’s official
Carpenter and Quincannon web site ] | [ official
Marcia Muller web site ] | [
Wikipedia entry for Bill Pronzini ]
Recommended by
Scott C. Bennett Martin Public Library
Have you read this? What did you think? Did you find this review helpful?
New reviews appear every month on the
Staff Recommendations
page of the BookGuide website. You can visit that page to see them all,
or watch them appear here in the BookGuide blog individually over the
course of the entire month. Click the tag for the reviewer's name to see
more of this reviewers recommendations!