I’ve been reading mysteries and thrillers since the 1970s, and I was
surprised to consider that I had never read of Patricia Cornwell’s
series featuring coroner Kay Scarpetta, until the libraries’ Just
Desserts mystery book discussion group discussed
Cruel & Unusual,
the fourth in the series, for our final meeting of 2016. Cornwell, with
the Scarpetta series, is credited with being one of the authors to
popularize the mystery sub-genre focusing on coroner and forensic work,
long before TV shows like CSI and Bones became huge hits (although
Quincy, M.E., with Jack Klugman, ran on NBC from 1976 to 1982).
In the Scarpetta novels, the private life and relationships of
Scarpetta, her co-workers and her relatives, take has much priority as
the mystery-solving. This is particularly the case in
Cruel & Unusual,
where partway through the book it is apparent that coroner Scarpetta is
being set up to take the fall in some shady dealings in the medical
examiner’s office. Supporting characters like homicide detective Pete
Marino, FBI profiler Benton Wesley, and Kay’s tech-savvy niece Lucy
Farinelli (a brilliant but anti-social 17-year-old in this novel), all
serve as major supporting characters in this volume. The plot of
Cruel & Unusual
was pretty straight-forward, but I did find myself getting interested
in the characters and their lives. While Scarpetta herself almost seemed
“too good to be true”, she was also quite a flawed character, which
made me care a little bit more about her and her fate. All in all, I’d
call this a strong mystery/thriller, although there is such character
development in each volume that it would be best to start this series at
the beginning, with 1990’s
Postmortem.
[ official
Patricia Cornwell web site ]
See other titles and authors read by the Just Desserts mystery fiction discussion group on the
Just Desserts archives
Recommended by
Scott C.
Bennett Martin Public Library
Have you read this one? What did you think? Did you find this review helpful?
New reviews appear every month on the Staff Recommendations
page of the BookGuide website. You can visit that page to see them all,
or watch them appear here in the BookGuide blog individually over the
course of the entire month. Click the tag for the reviewer's name to see
more of this reviewers recommendations!