A little over a year ago, I caught a repeat airing on PBS of Hallowed
Grounds, and enjoyed it very much. After stumbling across the DVD of
that special on the shelves at the downtown library, I found A Cemetery
Special right next to it, and the similar look of the packaging led me
to think both documentaries were similar in nature and tone. It turns
out, they were quite different, but equally recommendable in their own
ways.
A
Cemetery Special came first, in 2005. It was written, produced,
directed and narrated by Rick Sebak, a documentary producer who
specializes in what he calls “scrapbook documentaries”, a somewhat more
informal style of documentary storytelling featuring bits of home
movies, still photos, interview fragments of people’s personal memories,
and the input of both professional and amateur historians. In the case
of A Cemetery Special, the film crew visited an eclectic group of U.S.
cemeteries, from Vermont and Pennsylvania, to Key West, Florida and
Alaska. Sebak keeps a light tone throughout, interviewing colorful
locals and area historical experts, talking about the history of
“cemeteries” in the United States — the expansive, beautiful park-like
grounds that began with Mount Auburn Cemetery in Cambridge, MA in 1831.
As opposed to more bare-bones, utilitarian burial grounds and
graveyards, that had no aesthetically uplifting qualities. A Cemetery
Special is a celebration of landscaping, architecture, art, and history —
neither morbid nor depressing. It includes a look at a granite quarry
in Vermont, and artists creating unique tombstones and sculptures. This
is an enjoyable hour-long look at the beauty of some eternal resting
places, and may put you in the mood to stroll through Lincoln’s own
Wyuka Cemetery and appreciate the sculptures, obelisks and quirky
inscriptions.
On the other hand, Hallowed Grounds, while also only an hour long, is
written and produced by Robert Uth and Glenn Marcus, directed by Uth,
and narrated by Peter Thomas. It is a somber and reflective look at 22
of America’s overseas military cemeteries, where as many as 125,000
Americans lost in WWI and WWII, and 94,000 still listed as missing in
those conflicts, are either buried or memorialized. Ranging from tiny
Flanders Field American Cemetery (where 411 are buried), to Manila
American Cemetery in the Philippines (where over 53,000 are buried), the
film-makers include gorgeous footage of what these cemeteries looked
like around 2009 (when this film was first shown), filled with personal
stories of many of the noteworthy American soldiers buried in each. This
documentary is also filled with interviews, of ordinary Europeans who
come to these cemeteries to pay tribute to the Americans who helped
liberate their countries, and world historians and military historians
who shed light on the wars that left so many American soldiers buried
beneath foreign skies.
Unlike A Cemetery Story, Hallowed Grounds has very little humor to
it, and treats its subject matter with respect and reverence. It serves
to both entertain and educate, as well as to give the viewer a pause to
think of the lives lost in foreign wars of our parents’ and
grandparents’ generations.
Both documentaries are equally excellent and I highly recommend them.
I give Hallowed Grounds a full 10 rating for the thoroughness with
which it covers its unique subject matter, while A Cemetery Special
earns only an 8 — it was entertaining and informative but barely
scratches the surface on the subject of U.S. cemeteries, and doesn’t
even touch on any of the most famous, like Forest Lawn or Arlington or
Hollywood Forever or Saint Louis Cemetery #1 in New Orleans.
[If you enjoy this, you may also wish to try
Rest in Peace: A History of American Cemeteries by Meg Greene,
Hollwood Remains to Be Seen by Mark Masek,
Tombstones: 75 Famous People and Their Final Resting Places by Gregg Felsen,
Where Valor Rests: Arlington National Cemetery by the National Geographic Society,
American
Military Cemeteries: A Comprehensive Illustrated Guide to the Hallowed
Grounds of the United States, Including Cemeteries Overseas by Dean W. Holt. For those interested in local cemetery history, don’t miss Lincoln historian Ed Zimmer’s book
Wyuka Cemetery: A Driving and Walking Tour]
[
Internet Movie Database entry for A Cemetery Special ]
[
Internet Movie Database entry for Hallowed Grounds ] | [ PBS’ official
Hallowed Grounds web page ]
Recommended by
Scott C.
Bennett Martin Public Library
Have you watched either of these? What did you think? Did you find this review helpful?
New reviews appear every month on the Staff Recommendations page
of the BookGuide website. You can visit that page to see them all, or
watch them appear here in the BookGuide blog individually over the
course of the entire month. Click the tag for the reviewer's name to see
more of this reviewers recommendations!
Posts
