Silent Night: The Story of the World War I Christmas Truce
by Stanley Weintraub [940.4 Wei]
100
years ago at Christmas time Europe was literally entrenched in World
War I. It had been going since August 1914 and many thought it was
already overdue to be finished. The Western Front running through France
had become a muddy, icy mess as winter set in and the physical and
mental fatigue the soldiers felt sparked a 'spontaneous' 3-day ceasefire
in many quarters of the fighting. As the author puts it so aptly in one
of his chapter titles, there was "an outbreak of peace." Christmas Eve,
Christmas Day, and Boxing Day saw a deliberate lull in the war in
numerous places along the battle line. Both Germans and Allies took
pause to celebrate the holidays as best they could, and to reach out
across "No Man's Land" for conversation, exchanges of goods, singing,
putting up tannenbaum, tending to their dead, and even playing some
sports. Of course this was contradictory to the protocol of war and the
dictums of the high commands but yet it happened, in ultimately f utile
hopes it would mean a quick end to the conflict. Weintraub uses much
original source material to illustrate events, breaking them down into
real time. However, I did not care for his repeated technique of going
off on tangents of fictional descriptions and scenarios in the midst of
the factual accounts. I did appreciate, though, that he outlined a
variety of alternate-history outcomes if the Christmas Truce had
affected the course of the war in a more significant way. Weintraub also
succeeds at giving a good feel for everyday life in the trenches. This
is a good read for anyone interested in military history and general
history, and reminds us how extreme humanity's good and bad qualities
can be. -- recommended by Becky W.C. - Walt Branch Library [ see Becky's Reviewer Profile and more of her reviews ]
[ The Christmas Truce background page on History.com ] | [ Wikipedia page for Stanley Weintraub ]
Have you read this? What did you think? Did you find this review helpful?
New reviews appear every month on the Staff Recommendations page of the BookGuide
website. You can visit that page to see them all, or watch them appear
here in the BookGuide blog individually over the course of the entire
month. Click the tag for the reviewer's name to see more of this
reviewers recommendations!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment