The Zig Zag Girl and
Smoke and Mirrors
by Elly Griffiths (Griffiths)
In April 2021, the libraries’ Just
Desserts mystery fiction discussion group reading assignment was to sample one
or more of the series novels written by British mystery author Elly Griffiths.
Having long been a fan of stage magicians, and fondly remembering the 1973-1974
Bill Bixby TV series The Magician (featuring a crime-solving
prestidigitator), I decided to try The Zig Zag Girl, first in a 1950s-set series that
features a team-up between Max Mephisto, star stage magician, and his old Army
friend turned small town police detective Edgar Stephens. I ended up enjoying
the first one so much, I immediately read the second entry, Smoke and Mirrors as well. Both are very good, but
actually have somewhat different tones.
In The Zig Zag Girl, a brutal murder of a young woman
occurs, in which her body is cut into thirds, much like a stage illusion done
by Max Mephisto. The senior detective on the case, Edgar Stephens, served with
Max in WWII, in a unit called The Magic Men, comprised of magicians and
illusionists, who were tasked with creating large-scale illusions to fool the
Germans into believing the English coast was better-defended than it actually
was. Edgar calls on Max’s magic-trick background for advice, but then more
murders occur, each tied in some way to the old Magic Men unit. The characters
are engaging, with the magician angle in the 1950s providing a fresh viewpoint.
There’s a strong sense of place, in the British seaside town of Brighton. And
the mystery of a young woman who’s appeared who may have some connection to
Max’s past is intriguing. The mystery itself is fairly commonplace and easy for
the reader to solve, so the fun here is getting to know the characters.
In Smoke and Mirrors, two young children are murdered
and their bodies left to be discovered in a staged tableau, but are hidden by a
snowstorm. Edgar, once again in charge of the investigation once the bodies are
found, finds himself emotionally torn up by the events. Fortunately, Max is
appearing in a nearby musical comedy stage show, where his illusion skills are
put to good use, and is there to provide insight. New recurring characters are
introduced (who will become even more prominent in subsequent entries), and the
mystery is a lot more complex this time. But this one has a much darker feel
than the first one in the series.
I really like this series,
especially the friendly relationship between Edgar and Max, and look forward to
reading more — there are five so far with a sixth due in late 2021. If you like
a 1950s time frame, police procedurals, or the world of stage performers
(particularly magicians or illusionists), you’ll probably enjoy this series.
[If
you enjoy these, I recommend trying to track down the following TV shows
featuring stage magicians, illusionists or mentalists who help solve crimes: The Magician
(1973-74, 22 episodes), starring Bill Bixby; Blacke’s
Magic (1986, 13 episodes), starring Hal Linden and Harry Morgan; Jonathan
Creek (1997-2016 — a UK show with 26 episodes with several year
gaps between seasons) starring Alan Davies; The
Mentalist (2008-2015, 151 episodes) starring Simon Baker and Robin
Tunney; and Deception
(2018, 13 episodes) starring Jack Cutmore-Scott.]
[ official The “Brighton Mysteries” page on the official Elly Griffiths
web site ]
Recommended
by Scott C.
Bennett Martin Public Library — Public Service
Have you read or listened to these? What did you think? Did you find this review helpful?
New reviews appear every month on the Staff
Recommendations page of the BookGuide website. You can visit that
page to see them all, or watch them appear here in the BookGuide Blog
individually over the course of the entire month. Click the tag for the
reviewer's name to see more of this reviewer’s recommendations!
Hey mystery fans! Don't miss this month's Just Desserts mystery fiction discussion group
where we'll be discussing the "Jack McEvoy" series novel Fair Warning by Michael Connelly. The June 2021 Just Desserts meeting, returning to "in-person" meetings for the first time since February 2020, will be tonight at 6:30 p.m. to 7:45 p.m. in the 4th floor auditorium of the Bennett Martin Public Library downtown at 14th & "N" St. For more information, check out the Just Desserts schedule at https://lincolnlibraries.org/bookguide/book-groups/#justdesserts